|
A well-known, successful English defense
attorney, recovering from a heart attack, can't resist taking
on another challenging case, where circumstantial evidence all
points to the defendant's guilt.
"Witness for the Prosecution," adapted
from an Agatha Christie short story, is a gripping, riveting London
court room drama, that finds London's top defense attorney, Sir
Wilfrid Robarts (Charles Laughton) defending a man who is accused
of murder. This defendant, Leonard Vole (Tyrone Power), has overwhelming
circumstantial evidence that fingers him as the killer of a rich
widow, Mrs. French (Norma Varden). It seems that Mrs. French had
taken a liking to this inventor, in need of money, and had put
him in her will as the sole beneficiary of her whole estate. His
only alibi resides with his wife, Christine (Marlene Dietrich),
who decides to be a witness for the prosecution.
The story opens with Sir Wilfrid Robarts enduring
a forced convalescence, recovering from a heart attack he had
previously suffered in court. All under his concerned doctor's
orders, Sir Wilfrid is under the watchful eye of conscientious
Miss Plimsoll (Elsa Lanchester), his nurse, who not only administers
his medication, keeps him on a strict schedule, but also deprives
him of his much beloved cigars and brandy. Sir Wilfrid Robarts,
who is chaffing under such close supervision, and doing his best
to sneak a smoke and drink as well, decides to take this challenging
defense case, despite his doctor's advice to stick to bland, civil
court cases. He makes a deal with his doctor to forever quit murder
cases and take a vacation to Bermuda, after this last case.
Although, he isn't absolutely sure of his new
client's innocence, he believes enough in Leonard's innocence
to come up with a defense, based on theories that explain his
client's behavior, and that discredit other witnesses. What threatens
to sink the defense, however, is his client's wife, who switches
sides to be a prosecution witness.
This wonderful screenplay, full of twists and
turns, false misdirections, and a phenomenal surprise twist ending,
was written by Billy Wilder, Larry Marcus, and Harry Kurnitz,
and brings the spirit of Christie's story to the big screen, in
a very entertaining fashion, that is sure to please murder mystery
enthusiasts.
The brilliant pacing and direction by the talented
Billy Wilder not only results in the full potential of this classic
screenplay being realized, but also showcases the talent of the
gifted cast, who were given a terrific script to shine through
with their considerable talents. Their ensemble work together
is also top-notch. The script teases the audience, keeping them
guessing who is up to what, who is truly guilty, how Sir Wilfrid
will try to come up with a defense strategy to save his client,
and who is going to prevail.
Charles Laughton is superb as the clever Sir Wilfrid
as he skillfully tries to tackle this difficult case inside and
outside of the courtroom. It's easy to see why he was nominated
for the Best Actor Oscar. This is easily one of his best efforts.
Elsa Lanchester's fine supporting performance
earned her the Best Supporting Actress nomination, as the determined
and frustrated nurse, who has a most difficult assignment, as
she has to match wits with Sir Wilfrid.
The chemistry between Charles Laughton and Elsa
Lanchester sparkles on screen, as Elsa tries to deal with her
unco-operative patient. Their banter is amusing, as their comic
timing together is perfect. They bounce their lines off each other
effortlessly and naturally. As their relationship grows, they
mend their differences, as the trial proceeds. Charles and Elsa
were married in real life, when they did this picture together.
Marlene Dietrich, as Christine Vole, gives the
best performance of her career, and many feel she should've gotten
an Oscar nomination also. She pulls off her complicated character
without a hitch, and is very convincing, having fun confusing
the audience and other characters in the story.
Tyrone Power, as Leonard Vole, also gives a fine
performance, and also has fun keeping everyone guessing to what
his true character is, and if he did the evil deed or not. Sadly,
this film was his last before his untimely death.
My favorite scenes take place in the courtroom,
which are all done to perfection, offering great dramatic tension,
suspense, and keeping the audience guessing what is going to happen
next. The Laughton and Dietrich scenes are especially powerful,
as he cross examines her, trying to pull out of her what she is
hiding, and the real reason she is testifying against her husband.
"Witness for the Prosecution" is an
absolute classic in its genre, and is highly recommended for viewing.
It truly is "a movie to watch right till the end."
|