Tagline: "Sometimes its more than just coincidence."
Perhaps the testament to MAGNOLIA'S vision is that the plot itself
is so intensely difficult to summarize. On a surface level "MAGNOLIA"
exposes and develops the intricacies of nine different lives. But on
a deeper level there are overtones and taboos running through the film
that at times make the film feel like nine, two, and even one story
about something much larger than the general picture. In short, "MAGNOLIA"
follows the lives of nine people in the San Fernando Valley during a
twenty-four hour period that precludes a tumultuous ending. But the
question remains, do all these lives revolve around the making of a
TV game show "What Do Kids Know", or do the lives revolve
around the story of two fathers with estranged children and broken marriages?
The answer is both.
Intensely insecure on the inside, egomaniac on the outside, Frank T.J.
Mackey (Tom Cruise) is the estranged son of father Earl Partridge, producer
of the TV quiz show "What Do Kids Know", hosted by Jimmy Gator,
whose daughter, drug-addict Claudia, has estranged herself after a speculative
incident in her youth. Moreover, Earl?s trophy wife, Linda, is coping
with a mental breakdown as she battles her grief involving the acceptance
of her less than honorable intentions of her marriage to Earl previous
to his illness. Enter compassionate orderly nurse Phil Parma whose 24
hour mission is to track down Earl's son, the notorious Mackey, in honoring
a dying man's final wish. Tying in the plot is former whiz kid "What
Do Kids Know" contestant extraordinaire Donnie Smith, whose life
twenty years later has taken a turn for the worse. Meanwhile there's
a new kid in town, braniac Stanley, newest star of "What Do Kids
Know", who is about to crack from all the pressure of being a gifted
child; a pressure which stems from his father's insistence on his beating
a record set by none other than whiz-kid Donnie himself. As Stanley
and his predecessor Donnie struggle for normalcy and social acceptance,
in comes stock-clown of the police force, Officer Jim, whose sudden
interest in the equally desperate Claudia Gator might be the answer
to her long unanswered prayers.
"MAGNOLIA" is a film about coincidence, and yet, not about coincidence.
The opening scene frames "MAGNOLIA" with the notion that, though many
coincidences do occur in everyday life, on both a minute and grand scale,
end the end, there is ultimately some undetected explanation for the
intersections of these mere 'coincidences'. Thus goes the storyline
of Magnolia. The film weaves the nine characters lives in a tapestry-like
fashion of intricate knots and rows whereby each stage of the characters
life somehow results in a connecting force that will draw them into
the bigger picture being told. Though the story can be analyzed itself
from many different angles, and on many different levels of perspective,
ultimately, every critic will agree that, despite their opinion on its
success or failure, "MAGNOLIA" is attempting to unify with dramatic
irony. Nothing could be more definite of this than the final scene,
which, in biblical proportions and reference, explains fully the repercussions
of mankind's folly and ignorance.
The ending, if nothing else, will take you by complete surprise. Amidst
the dramatic suspense of a lengthy portrait is this sublevel tension
that is preparing for something bigger than the surface level climax
itself. The film's score, dialogue, and cinematography all work together
to let the audience know that there is the plot, and then there is the
bigger picture. On the surface level there exists the interactions of
the nine characters that work to build an obvious climax. But on a deeper
level there is a tension between what is and what could be, a sort of
paradoxical perspective that resorts back to Exodus 8:2, that will ultimately
be the final anti-climax to a film long building tension in its three-hour
run. The final scenes take you so much by surprise that at first you
can hardly grasp what has happened. Why did the director do this? What
does it mean? But at second glance, a composed reflection allows one
to correctly, if not personally conceive of the intentions of both the
director and the film.
"MAGNOLIA" is an extensively episodic ensemble that allows the different
story lines to bounce off one another and resonate throughout its duration
so that in the end, the overall effect is one complete, and risky storyline.
What could have been disastrous instead proved to be a marvelous endeavor
by a brilliantly intuitive mind. Anderson simply got it right, and did
it with panache equivalent if not altogether superior to his precursor,
'Boogie Nights'. In that respect, it should be noted that much of the
same cast from 'Boogie Nights' makes an encore appearance for Anderson's
new film.
"MAGNOLIA" is a creative, risky, entrepreneurial masterpiece that laughs
at the prospect of only six-plots by developing nine, and ultimately,
in the end, reduces them down to one, more largely unified story. In
the story are taboos of coincidence, death, survival, happiness, social
acceptance, and many other social values and themes that at times, seem
so utterly out of reach for the desperate; "MAGNOLIA" gives you a look
at nine of these 'desperate' people, who each choose to fight their
battle their own, individually distinct way.
Anderson's mosaic undulates with moments of intense climax/relaxation.
Though the final hour does start off slow, the ending quickly speeds
things back up and justifies the temporary lull in plot. All the while
there is of course intense character development and exposing going
on; to both character and audience alike. Nevertheless the ending is
altogether unpredictable and will either be an audience's favorite or
most hated scene. It could have potentially ruined the movie, it may
leave the less introspective critic perplexed. Whatever the personal
opinion of the audience, the ending to "MAGNOLIA" will be none other
than hugely controversial. But again, this was largely intentional on
behalf of Anderson and his creative genius.
So how does Magnolia hold one's attention for so long? Cinematography.
Quick snippets, short scenes, and character and plot variation speed
the film along rather nicely. At times it may seem as if the film just
cuts off mid-scene, but given time, the plot will resurrect itself later,
picking up where it left off with sometimes, an altered perspective.
Moreover, Anderson's attention to music, particularly that of 'Amie
Mann' plays a large part in setting the overtones for the film.
Lastly, the cast of "MAGNOLIA" is superb. Winning an award for Best
Supporting Actor by Chicago Film Critics Association Awards and Blockbuster
Entertainment, Tom Cruise delivers as well as the rest. The film is
tightly knit with sharp deliveries by each actor; the overall effect
of which is remarkably realistic and grand. "MAGNOLIA" presents the
grandest emotions on the scale's spectrum, and brings them to an audience
in a tangible, realistic manner via his production methods, and the
performances of his cast.
Though it didn't win an Oscar, "MAGNOLIA" was nominated for two, as
well as being nominated for and winning several other film critic awards.
It may seem weird upon first glance, unconventional in its methods and
plot development, but there is undeniably something about this film
that has made it a remarkable feat. May the serious drama lovers worldwide
enjoy it in all its glory.
Main Characters:
Tom Cruise plays Frank T.J. Mackey, the man whose claim to fame is
'Seduce and Destroy'; a campaign that allows him to hide his insecurities
developed as a young boy whose father Earl Partridge, left him to help
his mom fight cancer alone.
Julianne Moore plays Linda Partridge, the ailing Earl Partridge's trophy
wife who's decision to marry for money has come back to haunt her as
Earl lay dying in their home.
William H. Macy plays Donnie Smith; quiz kid extraordinaire whose childhood
fame prompted his parents to steal from their own son, leaving him estranged,
lonely, and desperate for social acceptance.
Philip Seymour Hoffman plays Phil Parma, Earl Partridge's overly compassionate
orderly nurse whose inept social skills are overshadowed by his caring
heart.
Melora Walters plays Claudia Wilson Gator, the estranged daughter and
coke-addict of TV show host Jimmy Gator.
Jeremy Blackman plays Stanley Spector, brainiac wonder whose peers
look at him like a freak, and whose father abusively uses his genius
to make money.
Jason Robards plays Earl Partridge, "What Do Kids Know" TV
show producer who is dying of brain cancer and wishes to see his estranged
son Frank Mackey before he passes away.
John C. Reilly plays Jim Kurring, inept cop with an overtly strong
social and ethical moral, who instantly falls for the neurotically traumatized
Claudia Gator.
Philip Baker Hall plays Jimmy Gator, cancer-stricken host of TV game
show "What Do Kids Know" and estranged father of troubled
daughter Claudia Gator.